Aug 14 / Dana Wilson-Szucs & Rebecca Lougheed

The Psychology of Automation and the Evolving Role of the Commercial Pilot

Automation has been part of airline flying for decades, but its role has grown from helpful assistant to ever-present partner in the cockpit. From the early autopilot of the 1930s to today’s AI-based decision support systems, the commercial pilot’s role has evolved into a mix of flying skill, system management, and strategic thinking.

For many, this shift is a win: automation has made aviation safer, reduced fatigue, and freed pilots to focus on the bigger operational picture. But it has also reshaped *how* pilots think, adapt, and manage themselves in an environment where the machine can do much of the work—and where the real challenge lies in staying mentally sharp when the workload feels light.

The Promise (and Paradox) of Automation

Automation works brilliantly at handling routine, predictable tasks. Freed from constant stick-and-rudder control, pilots can plan ahead, monitor complex systems, and anticipate challenges. 

The psychological shift is from active control to active oversight. That changes the brain’s job: you’re no longer continuously correcting flight path errors; you’re supervising a system that is usually correct.This might cause -what psychologists call - the "out-of-the-loop” effect when situational awareness slips because we’re not directly engaged. It’s not a failing; it’s human nature. Our brains naturally redirect attention when there’s no immediate demand, sometimes toward long-term planning (useful) and sometimes toward unrelated thoughts (less useful). The skill lies in managing that shift: using automation’s benefits to think ahead while keeping the ability to snap back into tactical mode the moment something changes. 

Practical ways to counter attention drift:

- Run mental “status checks”: Where are we? What’s the aircraft doing? What’s next?
- Use micro-scenarios: mentally rehearse a go-around, diversion, or system fault while monitoring automation.
- Keep a plan B and plan C in mind for each phase of flight, even if plan A is going smoothly.

Resilience: The Human Advantage

One thing automation doesn’t do well: handle the unexpected. Weather anomalies, novel system failures, complex social dynamics in the cockpit - these still belong in the human domain. Pilots provide what researchers call resilience: the ability to perceive, interpret, and act in situations where the playbook doesn’t apply.

If you’re becoming a pilot or even if you already are, developing that resilience is just as important as mastering the technology. But this safety net is only as strong as the skills and awareness behind it. 

How you can build resilience:

- Train for ambiguous problems, not just textbook failures, so you’re comfortable making decisions with incomplete information.
- Practice stress inoculation: short bursts of high workload in the simulator to learn how to stay calm and effective.
- Regularly hand-fly in a variety of conditions so motor skills and mental bandwidth for manual flying stay sharp.

The Shift in Training Philosophy

Flight academies and airline training departments are rethinking their approach to reflect the realities of a highly automated cockpit. In earlier decades, training was designed for pilots who manually flew most of the time, with automation as a helpful assistant. Today, the situation is reversed—automation is the default, and pilots must deliberately maintain manual proficiency.

Modern airline training follows Competency-Based Training (CBT) and Evidence-Based Training (EBT) principles, which focus on developing both technical and non-technical competencies rather than simply “training a task, checking a task.” Scenario-based training is one tool used to achieve this, alongside Crew Resource Management (CRM) and human factors training.

The goal is to equip pilots to manage automation effectively while maintaining the ability to intervene when needed. This includes training with a focus on Undesired Aircraft States (UAS)—situations where the aircraft is not doing what the crew intends. Pilots are taught to recognize, avoid, and recover from UAS promptly, whether they occur in manual or automated flight.

Automation is now deeply integrated into operations, but it exists to support, not replace, the pilot. As such, training aims to ensure that pilots can manage the aircraft, the automation, and the overall operation as a cohesive whole.

Situational Awareness in the Age of Glass Cockpits

For all its benefits, automation can be a slippery slope for situational awareness. Good situational awareness is not just “knowing what’s going on” — it’s perceiving, understanding, and anticipating. A pilot with strong situational awareness doesn’t just see a thunderstorm with a risk of turbulence or icing. They recognise the potential threat to their fuel, disruption to the routing, the need to consider the wind, airspace and other traffic when deciding which way to avoid it.

How to strengthen situational awareness in automated flight:
- Keep a mental map of your position, altitude, and future route at all times—even when the FMS shows it.
- Periodically predict the next three changes in flight parameters (speed, altitude, heading) and check if they match the automation.
- Use sensory cross-checking: listen for changes in engine tone, watch peripheral cues, feel control pressures—early warnings the screens might not show yet.

The Psychological Balancing Act

Research highlights five common human-automation challenges: overtrust, mistrust, workload mismanagement, situational awareness loss, and perceived loss of control.

These are psychological, not just technical, issues. The most effective pilots approach automation like a high-performing teammate:

- Trust it when appropriate —but verify continuously.
- Step in confidently when you detect an error or a better solution.
- Share mental models with your crew so both pilots are aligned on what the automation is doing and why.

 The right mindset matters as much as technical skill. Pilots who consciously monitor automation, practice manual flying, and stay curious about system behavior maintain a healthier psychological balance.

The Road Ahead: Collaboration, Not Competition

The future of aviation is not about replacing pilots—it’s about evolving the partnership between humans and machines. Artificial intelligence, for example, can help predict failures, optimize fuel use, and even detect pilot fatigue. But in a real crisis, the human element will still be decisive.

For pilots, this means the job is less about wrestling the controls for hours on end and more about being a systems manager, decision-maker, and safety strategist. The skillset is broader, the stakes are higher, and the need for mental agility is greater than ever.

Practical Takeaways for Pilots

- Stay “hands-on” when possible. Practice manual flying during suitable conditions to keep your skills fresh.
- Engage your mind even when systems are stable. Actively monitor, predict, and plan—don’t let automation lull you into passivity.
- Train for the unexpected. Scenario-based training and stress management techniques pay dividends when reality throws a curveball.
- Balance trust in automation with healthy skepticism. Understand its strengths, but always be ready to step in.
- Preserve situational awareness as a habit. Regularly cross-check the aircraft’s state, even when you think you know it.

Final Thoughts

Automation has taken commercial aviation to unprecedented levels of safety and efficiency. But as the systems grow smarter, the human role becomes more critical, not less. The psychology of automation reminds us that the real challenge is not in mastering the machine—it’s in mastering ourselves in an environment where the machine is our constant partner.

The best pilots of the future will be those who embrace technology without losing the mindset, skills, and resilience that have always defined the profession.
Our Advanced Interview Course teaches more than just "how to answer interview questions", it helps you understand you, and includes access to our 16PF questionnaire.